Here’s a newsflash for you: you just don’t get to know God’s will.
But… but… you say… I’ve been searching for it my whole life! Let me ask you a question. How’s that going for you? Not that well, eh? No wet fleeces on dry ground? No angels appearing to lead you out of Sodom? No pigs flying overhead?
I’ll be frank. I’m sick of this evangelical culture geared to constantly looking for some clue, some sign that they’re doing the right thing, as if somehow you’re going to look up one day and see “In this sign conquer”. Where in scripture do people get this stuff? What is it that makes them second-guess themselves under the guise of searching out God’s will? God’s will is inscrutible. His thoughts are way, way above anything you can ever imagine (see, that one’s in the Bible, people) and if you did get to know his will, you probably would be wondering why the Fitzgerald he’s doing that!
See, I think what hinders us from just getting it is partly the way we’re curious little buggers, us humans, but also the way we word this idea. Look at it. “God’s will” means what exactly? Does it mean his plan for our lives, or just what he would have us do? If the latter, why use the word “will” at all? Why not just say “I want to do what God would have me do”, which is much, much clearer? Plus, “finding” this “will” implies that it’s a big secret and that somehow we’ve got to dig and dig and dig to search it out as if we’re stuck in some sort of maze with a definite solution. Not only is what God wants you to do not that hard to figure out (generally) considering that he wrote a book and gave it to the Church, but it seems we like to trade in the shovel of scripture for the teaspoons and dull sticks of signs in the sky. You see what I mean when I say that out wording is unhelpful?
The classical solution to understanding what God wants is that he’s got a plan, you’re part of the plan, and you don’t get to know the plan. You probably shouldn’t even want to know the plan. What you do get to know, however, is that the plan is a good one (again, that one’s in scripture: Jeremiah 29:11-13). The rest is up to you. That’s right. But it’s not like you get set adrift in a sea of moral indifference and any choice you make is just fine; you don’t get to toss down a deck and pick up whatever card you like. What you need to know for life - indeed, just about everything you need to know to live properly - is in what we like to call God’s revealed will. That is to say, scripture.
Here’s a thought. Maybe if you stopped looking for God’s will in the advice of friends, circumstances, talents, the alignment of planets, and spotted goats; and instead cracked open those scriptures everyone keeps talking about as the basis for your faith you might understand a little better what’s going on and how to respond. Isn’t that simple? Almost too simple!
Of course, my circles are abundantly clear in our separation from typical evangelicalism, but we still fall victim to this jargonism; I can’t tell you the number of times I’ve attended Bible Studies and focus groups and discussions on “Finding God’s Will For Your Life”. I also can’t tell you how many times these things have had absolutely nothing to do with God’s will (except in a cursory manner) and instead focused on what smells suspiciously like “Making Sensible Plans”.
But isn’t that what it’s really about anyways? How often will someone come along and say “Oh, well the Lord gave you talents and you should use them!” as if this is somehow the Grand Revelation and the Big Red Key to unlock the Big Red Door? It’s like, well duh! Some people have talents that lead them to preach; I’m not saying no one will ever feel that “call”, or that God won’t give you a sign. But at the end of the day, when someone feels called to preach, the elders who examine this man don’t ask for audio or video of the experience, dust him for God’s fingerprint, or point the Bible at him to see if it magically flips open to the Great Commission. They examine him against the rule of scripture, and they should also be examining him to see if he has the raw stuff of preaching. (As an aside, there are a great number of preachers out there that should have been strongly discouraged from ever becoming preachers and pastors but weren’t because the subjective “call” is given so much more weight over the objective criterion as spelled out in the Bible and plain for the eye to see. Some people just don’t cut it, and should have been sent back to plant corn or write computer code or become doctors. And these things aren’t particularly hard to determine, I don’t think.)
But at the end of the day, when you’re deciding if it’s God’s Will ™ for you to become either a lawyer or a welder, are you really prepared to say that only one of these choices is legitimate in view of God’s pre-ordinance? Why should you? Pick the one that makes the most sense: if you are a great communicator and can argue a point well and convince people of your position, become a lawyer. If you really, really like the way sparks hit the floor and bounce a bit before flickering out, hey, become a welder. Either one is a vocation in which you can glorify God.
Frankly, God gave you common sense - at least, I hope he did - so use it. It’s not really that hard.
Let me give you an example of the ridiculous frilled shirts that go under the suit jacket of Finding God’s Will, and one that has personally touched me many, many times. A guy is going out with a girl. Somebody with a vested interest - and they only do this when they have a vested interest and they think that you’re wrong in what you’re doing - says something along the lines of, “Well, you should cool things down between the two of you and break off contact, and if it lasts through that, you’ll be more sure that it’s God’s will.” And of course, whenever I hear that, I get - shall we say - slightly frustrated. First off, what the Hemingway kind of logic is that? Relationships take work (just like cars take gasoline and oil changes, and babies take breastmilk and diaper changes), and when you truly distance yourself from it, well, it begins to fall apart. Does anyone suggest that you stop adding gasoline to your car and if it keeps running you should be pretty darn sure that God wants you to have that car? Of course not, because it’s just a car and God’s will for our car doesn’t often enter our minds regardless of the fact that God’s plan involves cars, pomegranites, cheese, and serrated knives. And yes, a car is a whole lot less important than a life partner.
The logic is at best misguided and probably worse, deceitful. Everyone tacitly knows that a relationship falls apart when you stop working on it. How is that finding God’s will? If you stop working on it, well, you’re making it stop working. And if someone pipes up and says, “Well if it didn’t just happen, it must not be God’s will!” as if a romance just blooms and blossoms in a cold basement without water, that’s not finding anything remotely earth-shattering. No, dummy, either way, you’re imposing your own will on the situation. If you keep working, maybe it keeps working. If you stop working, it stops working for sure. In that light, the rhetoric of “stepping out on faith” becomes abundantly clear - where did God ever say in scripture that you need to be completely and utterly stupid to find out what God wants? It’s like saying that the best way to find out whether or not gravity is God’s will for your life is to step off a bridge; but then, we all know how that works out.
But let’s cut the - if you’ll excuse my French - bullshit and stop wrapping the coal of making good decisions in the Christmas bows and ribbons of finding God’s will. If you were to tell me that sometimes you need to step back from things in order to get a good perspective on them, then I’d agree heartily. Sometimes a little distance comes in handy. Step back, evaluate based on scripture and good old common sense, and if things seem alright, fine and away you go. I would think this more analogous to dropping a rock off the aforementioned bridge to see it gravity is still working. Or more to the point, you don’t need to shoot yourself in the head to find out if the pistol you’re holding is loaded. Maybe shoot some squirrels. And if that works out, maybe it’s God’s will for your life that you join the army.
Even Augustine said - and although he isn’t scripture, it adds some weight to the argument - “Love God, and then do whatever you like.” You’ll read this and it’ll seem like a contradiction. But no, that’s the genius of it: if you’re loving God, what you want will conform to his will. If you’re living your life to “glorify God and enjoy him forever” like the Catechism says, saturating your decisions in scripture and prayer (something I have neglected to dwell on until now… sorry), your decisions are going to have a natural bent toward pleasing God.
Of course it’s not always that easy: some things are ambiguous. But it’s better that way, really. If you got to see God’s plan for you life, being human, I can almost guarantee you wouldn’t like it that much. Which is probably the plan behind not getting to know the plan. But let’s stop it with the jargon, already. As Gordon Korman once said, you keep adding sugar to coffee, and eventually it comes out tasting like diesel fuel.
dan (thinks the wording of “finding God’s will” is probably the least helpful wording ever)
I’m adding a little postscript - I thank God for it being his will that I not post this fresh off the keys - to point out a relevant scripture: “Delight yourself in the LORD, and he will give you the desires of your heart.” That’s from Psalm 37:4. Argue with that. I dare you.
Tags:
opinions,
ruminations,
scripture